A Checklist for Judging Room Sound Before You Commit
Callum Reid sets out the questions worth answering about your room, your microphones and your mix before settling on an acoustic and audio plan for live television.
6 min read
Start with the room, not the equipment
Most of the audio problems we are called in to fix are not microphone problems. They are room problems that a better microphone only makes more obvious. Before anyone talks about gear, stand in the space where the programme will be made and listen to it properly. Clap once and follow the sound as it dies away. Speak at normal volume from where the presenter will sit and notice whether your own voice comes back at you with a ring or a hollow edge.
A bare room with hard walls and a flat ceiling will flatter nobody on air. Speech loses clarity, consonants smear, and a band in the same space becomes a wash. It helps to know early whether the room needs treatment, a change of layout, or simply a different position for the set.
Walk the room with the person who will mix it. Ten minutes of listening with a producer and an engineer together saves hours of argument later, because everyone has heard the same thing.
- Clap once and listen for ringing or flutter
- Speak from the presenter's seat and note any hollow tone
- Check ceiling height and the hardness of the walls
- Listen for hum from lights, air handling or fridges
Noise you can hear and noise you cannot
Rooms carry sound you stop noticing after five minutes. A ventilation fan, a humming transformer, traffic on the harbour road, a corridor with a heavy door. A microphone has no such habit of tuning things out, and a live broadcast gives you no second take to remove it afterwards.
Record a minute of the empty room with the equipment you plan to use and play it back on headphones. Whatever you hear in that minute will be under every word of the programme. Some of it can be switched off for the duration of the show, some can be reduced by moving a source or a microphone, and some means choosing another time of day.
Ask who else uses the building and when. A venue that is quiet at ten in the morning may not be at four, and a rehearsal should be held at the hour of the broadcast so you hear the real conditions.
- Record a silent minute and play it back on headphones
- Identify what can be switched off during the show
- Rehearse at the same hour as the broadcast
Questions about treatment before you buy anything
Treatment does not have to mean covering every wall. The aim is to control the reflections that reach the microphones and to stop the room adding its own voice. Often a small number of well-placed panels behind the cameras, a rug or soft flooring under the set, and curtains on the worst reflective surface make the largest difference.
Ask what problem each piece of treatment is meant to solve and where it will sit. Panels hung where no microphone benefits from them are an expense and nothing more. Think too about the cameras: absorbers must stay out of shot, and anything near a lighting position has to be safe around heat.
Decide whether the treatment is permanent or needs to be taken down after each use. A hired venue and a dedicated studio call for very different answers, and portable screens can be a sensible middle path for a space you do not own.
- Name the problem each panel is meant to solve
- Keep absorbers out of shot and clear of hot lights
- Decide early whether treatment is fixed or portable
Microphone choice and placement
The right microphone is the one that suits the voice, the room and the way the person moves. A presenter who sits still behind a desk can use a different arrangement from a guest who gestures and turns. Lapel microphones are discreet but pick up clothing noise and chest resonance, while boom and desk microphones sound more natural but must sit close and stay out of the picture.
Distance matters more than price. A modest microphone placed correctly will beat an expensive one placed carelessly. Check that each person has a clear, consistent distance from their microphone and that nothing, such as a paper pile or a laptop, sits between them.
For music, think about how many sources compete for the same space and whether the stage sound is already loud enough to bleed into every open microphone. Plan the layout on paper before the day, not at the sound check.
- Match microphone type to how each person moves
- Keep a steady distance from mouth to microphone
- Remove paper, laptops and mugs from the sound path
- Plan stage microphone layout on paper beforehand
Mixing, monitoring and a plan for things going wrong
A live mix is made in real time, so the person doing it needs to hear what the audience will hear. That means decent monitoring in a quiet enough space, not a pair of headphones in a noisy gallery. Agree who is responsible for sound and who they take instructions from, so that a producer's request in the middle of a programme does not arrive from three directions.
Think about what happens when something fails. A dead radio microphone, a battery that gives out, a cable pulled loose by a passing foot. Keep a spare in reach, label every channel clearly, and decide in advance which source takes over if the main one is lost.
Finally, listen back to a recording of the rehearsal before the broadcast. Problems that go unnoticed in the room are often plain on a recording, and there is still time to correct them.
- Give the mixer a quiet, accurate way to monitor
- Agree a single line of instruction for sound
- Keep spare microphones and batteries within reach
- Review a rehearsal recording before going live
None of these questions needs special equipment to answer, only time and attention before the day. If most of them have clear answers, you are probably ready to decide what treatment and audio setup the programme needs. If several are still open, that is useful to know. Bring them to a conversation with an engineer and settle them before the schedule tightens, while there is still room to change the plan.
Further reading from the Journal
-
Six Common Mistakes in Concert and Festival Broadcast
Most trouble at a stage broadcast starts well before the first song. Ewan Gordon goes through the slips that cost crews time and sound quality, and how to avoid each one.
-
Noise Floor, Room Tone and Clean Speech: Audio Terms Explained
Fiona MacLeod explains the audio terms heard in every gallery, from noise floor to room tone and reverberation time, and why each one matters for speech and live music on air.
-
The Paper and Software Behind a Live Show That Runs to Time
Ewan Gordon describes the run sheets, rehearsal plans and backup lists the team uses to plan a live broadcast, and why a plain document often does more than clever equipment.
Get in touch
- Phone
- 01463 725418
- Write to us
- hello@flairuni.net